Why Google Ads reports about ten times your real leads
Some conversion actions Google adds by default count taps and clicks that are not enquiries. How one local service account reported nearly ten times its real leads, and how to check yours.
On this page
Google Ads can report many times more conversions than you have real enquiries, because some conversion actions count things that are not leads. On one of our client accounts, a local appliance repair business, the last 30 days showed about ten times as many conversions as real leads. The rest came from actions that Google creates or hosts itself, and they were quietly feeding the numbers we used to judge the campaigns. If you pay for Ads management, or manage your own, this check is worth doing before you trust any cost per lead.
What does Google Ads count as a conversion by default?
It counts whatever actions are in your goals, and some of those are created or hosted by Google and count taps that are not enquiries. Roughly one in ten of the conversions on that account reflected a real enquiry: a website contact form, a tap on the phone number link on the website, or a call placed from the ad and recorded through call reporting. The rest was made up mainly of:
- Clicks to call, an action Google hosts, which counts a tap on the call button inside the ad itself. It was set to count every tap, to be a primary action, and sat in the account's default "Contact" goal across all five campaigns. It made up a bit over a third of all conversions.
- Local actions, other engagements and Local actions, directions, which come from Google's own listings and maps activity. Together they were about two fifths of all conversions. They sat in goals not used by any campaign, so they inflated the "all conversions" column without feeding bidding.
A tap on a call button is not nothing, because some of those people do ring. But a tap does not tell you whether a call connected or how long it lasted, so it is a weaker signal than a recorded call or a submitted form.
Primary and secondary actions
Each conversion action in Google Ads is either primary or secondary. Primary actions count in the Conversions column and are used by automatic bidding. Secondary actions are recorded for your information and do not steer bids. The trap with Google-hosted actions is that they often arrive as primary by default and sit in a goal you never chose. On this account, Clicks to call was primary, and the way Google's own controls are laid out meant we could only deal with it by taking its goal out of use.
Why it matters
A bid strategy and a human reader both trust the conversion column. If it includes call-button taps and map engagement events, three things go wrong.
- Cost per lead looks far better than it is. Divide spend by all the reported conversions and the account looks efficient. Divide by the real leads and the cost per lead is about ten times higher.
- Keywords look like they convert when they do not. The search terms report shows conversions per term. Those include the Clicks to call, so the "converting" terms are not necessarily lead terms.
- Automatic bidding learns the wrong thing. If you switch to Maximise conversions or a target cost per action while the junk is counted, the system optimises for the easiest actions, which are call taps and map clicks.
The same account had the opposite problem earlier. In September it had no working website conversion actions at all, and Google recorded almost no conversions for the whole month. So the numbers were too low before they were too high, and neither said much about real leads.
How do you find which actions are inflating your numbers?
Google's help page About primary and secondary conversion actions covers the setting that decides whether an action steers bidding. Our own steps follow.
How we found and fixed it
We listed every action in the Ads goals summary and compared each one with what the website itself recorded. That showed which three were Google-hosted and which were real.
The fix is a few steps, and it deletes nothing:
- In Goals, then Summary, expand the "Contact" goal.
- Move the real action, the website phone number click, into a lead goal such as "Submit lead form".
- Turn off "account default" on the Contact goal so that it no longer counts toward campaigns.
After this, the Contact goal was used by none of the five campaigns, which we checked.
A detail that matters: you cannot simply mark Clicks to call as secondary. Its optimisation setting is greyed out because Google hosts the action. The workaround is to take its goal out of use, not to edit the action.
What to do with your own account
- Open Goals, then Summary, and list every conversion action.
- For each, note the source. Treat Google hosted and automatically created actions as suspect.
- Check whether each is primary and which campaigns' goals include it.
- Compare your total with a count you trust, such as form entries in your inbox and calls in your phone log, for the same dates.
- Until the two roughly agree, do not use automatic bidding for conversions, and do not rank keywords by conversions.
Do this check once a quarter and after any change to goals.
Why this is the first job in Ads management
Cleaning up conversions comes before changing bids, ads or budgets, because every later decision rests on those numbers. When we manage an account, you keep your own Google Ads account, add us as a manager, and pay Google directly for your clicks. We charge for the management, which is the Ads management add-on at $549 a month, month to month. Our pricing page has the details. For the tracking side of the same problem, see why Google Ads tracking breaks without anyone noticing.
Common questions
- Why does Google Ads show more conversions than I have leads?
- Google Ads can count actions that are not enquiries, such as taps on a call button in the ad, direction requests and other engagement events. If those are included in your conversion goals, the total overstates leads.
- Where do I check which actions are counted?
- In Google Ads, open Goals, then Summary, and look at each conversion action: its source, whether it is primary or secondary, and which campaigns use its goal. Actions marked Google hosted deserve a close look.
- Should I use Maximise conversions bidding with inflated conversions?
- Not until the conversion actions are clean. Automatic bidding optimises for whatever it is told counts, so it will chase the easy, low-value actions.
Want a website that turns readers into customers?
A custom site, hosting and upkeep for one monthly fee, with your leads and Google results in a dashboard you can check any time.